CYPCS response to the Online Safety Act inquiry

In 2023 the UK government passed the Online Safety Act which gives the government the power to designate, suppress, and record a wide range of online content that they deem illegal or harmful to children.

It has received a lot of criticism for being very broad in scope, having little evidence that the measures it allows will be effective, and having sections that are difficult or impossible to actually implement.

On November 19 2026 the Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland published a response to the House of Lords Communications and Digital Committee about its implementation and impact, and is the largest credible source I’ve seen explaining the problems.

I recommend reading the full text of the Evidence to UK Parliament House of Lords Communications and Digital Select Committee Inquiry: The Online Safety Act: Implementation and Impact. I thought I would extract some quotes that seem most pertinent, but honestly it is very short and my quotes feel like most of it.

significant concern that the ban is likely to restrict children and young people’s access to information and right to free expression, while failing to prevent them being exposed to online harms on social media

A ban is likely to reduce pressure on companies to ensure their platforms are safe for young people

The UK Government’s own research on young people’s circumvention of age restrictions shows nearly two in five had successfully bypassed age checks

a ban for under 16s will simply further undermine children’s safety online

When children aren’t ‘supposed’ to be on social media, companies are unlikely to prioritise their safety on the platform

distracts from the real problem which is companies prioritising profit over harm